Lesbian ISO* Sperm (Or, Selections from the Heart)

“What are you thinking?” I asked my mom, after a silence. The afternoon light danced on her white, quilted bedspread. I was 19, and had just told her I’m a lesbian.

“Well,” she responded carefully, “I always wondered if you were gay, so I’m not surprised… it’s just that I always pictured you getting married and having kids.”

“But I still want that. I just want it with a woman,” I replied, without missing a beat.

Cut to almost 20 years later. My mother and I are FaceTiming between NYC (me) and Toronto (her). We are each staring at an excel spreadsheet on our respective laptops. The left column is a series of seemingly random numbers - "1357", "2398", "1402" and so on. The top column reads: “Eye Color,” “Hair,” “Health,” “Happiness,” “Intelligence,” “Occupation,” “Talents,” “Skills,” “Looks,” “Past Pregnancies” and “Notes”. We are rating sperm donors on various attributes, on a scale of one to five.

How do you choose a donor? I had recently seen the documentary “Happy” by Roco Belic, which revealed the latest research that happiness is genetically inherited by 50%. (The other 50% comes from connection with community, compassion and service to others, exercise, and gratitude). So, I read between the lines of the donor essays, to try to determine which donors seemed generally happy.

Health was another very important factor to me. My relatives live into their late 90’s, so I eliminated donors with extended families who had significant heart or cancer issues. I have worked intensely with special needs children and was also cautious about donors with too many cousins with ADD or learning disabilities. Along those lines, I sometimes wonder if my father is on the spectrum, and had heard about some studies that concluded that descendants of engineers had an increased likelihood of being autistic. So I avoided engineers or people who seemed anti-social, as I didn’t want my geeky genes doubling up with theirs.

I am a performer, and worried that if my artistic genes doubled up with another artist’s, my child wouldn’t have organizational skills, so I specifically sought out lawyers or something equally practical. I also made notes on the quality of their writing style and academic scores, to seek out intelligence.

Everyone in my family has blue eyes and since I was completely overwhelmed with the selection, I narrowed them down further by only choosing blue eyes. My best friend growing up had gorgeous blonde hair (I have golden brown), so I decided it might be fun to have a blondie. I didn’t make it a deciding factor, but did record their hair color in the spreadsheet. I also wanted to choose someone who was attractive in a way that was familiar to me, like they could be someone I would date, or a cousin, so that my child would fit in with my family look-wise.

And finally, I preferred donors with past pregnancies, as I wanted to increase my chances for success.

I was so overwhelmed with the responsibility of selection, that I actually looked at donors from almost every sperm bank in America. In the end I went with California Cryobank, because they had the largest selection and a very user-friendly database.

I narrowed it down to about five. Any of them would have been great, but I made my final selection based on an emotional pull. I was in love with one of the donor’s photos. He looked like a boy I had a crush on when I was 12, so it seemed perfect.

I did several IUI’s and IVF’s with that sperm. I kept asking my doctors if I should try other sperm, but they reassured me there was no scientific data to support the theory of egg/sperm incompatibility, so I stayed true to my initial selection.

After about a year and a half, it became apparent that due to my low ovarian reserve, my egg quality wasn’t good. I moved to egg donor and my mom and I made another spreadsheet, applying our newfound sperm searching skills to egg donors.

The egg donor I finally chose had had a full genetic panel done (116 genes) and they found 1 mutation. The sperm donors in most banks just have 13 genes screened. So in order to be thorough, I needed my sperm donor to get tested. California Cryobank contacted my sperm donor several times but he never responded. I decided it wasn’t worth the risk, so I contacted all the sperm banks again, to find out if there were any donors who had already had that specific gene tested. They sent me their lists and I looked through the options. One stood out to me in particular. He was gorgeous, smart, caring and musical. I didn’t mind him being a musician this time, as I wasn’t using my own eggs and the egg donor only had average music ability. And, he was a Willing to Be Known Donor, meaning my child could contact him when he was 18, so it seemed perfect.

My first attempt with an egg donor worked, so I now have a gorgeous, creative, smart and energetic nine month old, who everyone comments looks just like me. And when I complain to those who know me how intense he is, they laugh and say, “I wonder where he gets that from?!” Whether it’s nature or nurture, there isn’t a child in the world who is more my son. He is just now obsessively learning to walk, with an intensity so fierce, I can only compare it to the intensity with which I made the selection to create him.

The other day, when we were in a Mommy and Me class, another parent was commenting on how beautiful and advanced he is. She then joked, “Whatever recipe you used to create him, it was a good one.” “Thanks,” I knowingly smiled.

Little does she know how perfect that word is. Recipe. As parents of donor children, we get to be extra proud, because we used not only our biology to create our children, but our minds and conscious hearts as well. And as an artist, I can say it truly felt like a creative process.

*In search of

Athena Reich is an award winning actress, singer/songwriter and writer. Reich is currently featured in “haveababy,” a documentary about In Vitro Fertilization, from Oscar-nominated filmmaker, Amanda Micheli. Her newest project, “Baby Steps,” on GOMag.com, is a webseries which follows her journey as a single, lesbian mother by choice, who dealt with infertility.

Previous Post   Next Post


Categories Authors

Seeking a professional?
Find physicians, mental health professionals, complementary care providers, surrogacy, egg donation and sperm donation agencies, adoption agencies, lawyers, pharmacists.

Find a Professional